Date of Award
2026
Document Type
Dissertation
Degree Name
Doctor of Education (EdD)
Department
Organizational Leadership
First Advisor
Carline Sinkler
Second Advisor
Barbara Bartels
Third Advisor
Sasha Crowley
Abstract
Purpose: This comparative study qualitatively explores how organizational leaders in the United States and Africa apply transformational leadership to implement Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, focusing on the challenges they face, the leadership strategies they employ, and how effective strategies in each region might be adapted for cross-regional improvement. Methodology: Using a qualitative comparative case study design grounded in Bass and Riggio's (2006) four dimensions of transformational leadership, the study drew on semi-structured interviews with 12 organizational leaders (six from the United States and six from Africa) including executive, DEI-specific leadership roles across nonprofit, private, and public sectors. Data was analyzed using Braun and Clarke's (2006) thematic analysis approach.
Findings: The findings showed that U.S. leaders relied on formalized DEI structures and policy-driven accountability, while African leaders embedded DEI in community-centered, culturally responsive practices, reflecting Hofstede's (2011) individualism-collectivism dimension. Leaders in both regions reported organizational resistance and structural barriers, though these diverged sharply by region; both identified collaborative leadership and a shared vision as central to advancing DEI. An unexpected finding was the centrality of Ubuntu, an African philosophy of communal interdependence and shared humanity, which emerged as a guiding ethic for African leaders' DEI practices and offered a culturally grounded counterpoint to largely Western, individualist assumptions underlying transformational leadership theory.
Conclusion: The findings show that effective DEI depends less on a single universal model than on leaders' capacity to adapt shared principles, such as trust and stakeholder involvement, to distinct cultural contexts. The unexpected development of Ubuntu as a spontaneously named leadership philosophy suggests that transformational leadership theory, developed largely in Western contexts, meets existing frameworks of inclusion rather than introducing new ones. This study advances understanding of effective DEI practices by showing that strategic leadership succeeds not by exporting one region's approach to another, but by remaining responsive to the communities it serves.
Recommendations: Future research should expand the sample across a broader range of African nations and USA organizational sectors, employ longitudinal designs to track DEI outcomes over time, and examine how leadership philosophies such as Ubuntu might be formally integrated with transformational leadership theory.
Recommended Citation
Annan Kingsley, Marthe, "Comparing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Initiatives in the USA and Africa: Challenges, Leadership Strategies, and Cross-Regional Adaptations" (2026). Dissertations. 664.
https://digitalcommons.umassglobal.edu/edd_dissertations/664